Following my review of this one I got a note from the author. It said:
I'm Bill Condon. As explained to another reader, Katrina, the ending was based on an actual incident that happened to me. There is no magic bullet to cure very dark depression, so I wrote that open ending, which to me showed that there were hard times ahead, but if you kept on going and hoping, you had a chance.
I responded:
Hi Bill,
Thanks for your explanation. It is wonderful to get feedback on my review from the author.
I understand your point. Unfortunately, that doesn't change my opinion. I agree there is no magic bullet cure, and maybe there isn't even a truly satisfactory way to end the story, but as a reader I just would have really liked to see something pointing which direction Bri was heading - good, bad or otherwise. The book was so good up to that point that I couldn't say I didn't like it, but I can't say I loved it which up to the ending I did, because of that truly (in my humble opinion) far too abrupt ending. I truly felt like pages were missing. But it was a great story to that point.
You are a fantastic writer and obviously have truly profound stories to tell.
Thanks,

Thanks for your explanation. It is wonderful to get feedback on my review from the author.
I understand your point. Unfortunately, that doesn't change my opinion. I agree there is no magic bullet cure, and maybe there isn't even a truly satisfactory way to end the story, but as a reader I just would have really liked to see something pointing which direction Bri was heading - good, bad or otherwise. The book was so good up to that point that I couldn't say I didn't like it, but I can't say I loved it which up to the ending I did, because of that truly (in my humble opinion) far too abrupt ending. I truly felt like pages were missing. But it was a great story to that point.
You are a fantastic writer and obviously have truly profound stories to tell.
And a last response from Bill:

Nice to hear from you, and I entirely understand your point of view.
Happy Christmas.
Bill.
It was truly a pleasure for me to get feedback from Bill on his perspective.
No comments:
Post a Comment